Episode Title Director Writer(s) Premiere
51 Virtual Celebrities May 6, 2009
50 Blaseball April 29, 2009
49 Artsy Fartsy Games April 22, 2009
Jeff, Dan Klein from The Onion, John Gabrus and Patrick review/make fun of Flower (PS3), Bit.Trip Beat (Nintendo) and Noby Noby Boy (PS3).
48 Power Pad April 15, 2009
Jeff, Chris Finnegan, Kevin, Patrick review Nintendo's Power Pad.
47 Mega Man 22nd-ish Anniversary Celebration April 9, 2009
Jeff, Geoff Haggerty and Alexander Zalben from Elephant Larry, Patrick celebrate Mega Man by playing past incarnations of Mega Man.
46 Ninja Gaiden, Then & Now April 2, 2009
Jeff, Simon Rich and Patrick play the Ninja Gaiden franchise.
45 Girly Game Slumber Party March 26, 2009
Jeff, Sarah, Elaine Carroll, Kate Spencer and Patrick review videogames marketed to girls: Barbie Horse Adventures (Wii), Purr Pals (Wii) and We Cheer (Wii), all of which girls find insulting/not appealing to girls.

Jeff and Sarah face-off in We Cheer (Sarah wins).

44 Beer Pong March 19, 2009
Jeff, Jake, Dominic Dierkes and DC Pierson from Derrick Comedy, and Patrick review Pong Toss! Frat Party Games (Wii).
43 Sonic the Hedgehog, What Happened? March 12, 2009
42 TV Games March 5, 2009
41 Stereotypes and Street Fighter February 26, 2009
40 Comic-Con pt. 2 February 19, 2009
39 Comic-Con pt. 1 February 12, 2009